Steelman: technology and tools

Choose one claim below that you disagree with. If you happen to agree with all three, you may pick a different claim about using technology and tools that you usually disagree with. ① Junior (early-career) practitioners should be barred from using AI tools. ② Internal documentation should be minimized, and the more important something is, the more it should be conveyed verbally and in person. ③ Dashboards measuring each person's work performance should be made visible to all employees.

State your chosen claim in one line at the top, then step into the shoes of a reasonable person who genuinely believes it and lay out the strongest possible version. The goal is a version that person would read and admit, 'You made my case better than I could.' Give at least three distinct reasons supporting the position, and pre-empt one likely counterargument in that person's own voice. Don't write a single line that reveals what you actually think.